Justia Badge
LACBA Badge
Avvo Clients Choice Award 2018
The State Bar of California
Best Lawyers
Lawyers of Distinction
Super Lawyers - Matthew Barhoma 2022
Super Lawyers - Matthew Barhoma Rising Stars
Court TV
Forbes
Fox News
KTLA 5
Law & Crime Trial Network
People
Top 40
Yahoo News
Los Angeles Times

Appealing a Criminal Sentence in California

Quick answer: In California, you can file a sentencing appeal along with an appeal of the conviction, or by itself, within 60 days after judgment in a felony case and 30 days in a misdemeanor case. The appeal can challenge a sentence the law does not allow (an unauthorized sentence), a sentence based on legal error, such as an upper term imposed without the findings Penal Code section 1170(b) now requires, a failure to apply a new law that reduces punishment, a refusal to exercise discretion the judge did not realize it had, multiple punishment barred by Penal Code section 654, errors in custody credits or fines, and, rarely, a sentence so disproportionate it is cruel or unusual. The Court of Appeal does not substitute its judgment for the trial judge’s on discretionary choices, but it does reverse when the judge misunderstood the law or the scope of its discretion.

Key Takeaways

  • Sentencing errors are among the most common grounds for relief in California criminal appeals, because the sentencing laws have changed repeatedly since 2018.
  • Usually, you must object to discretionary sentencing choices at the hearing, or you forfeit the issue (People v. Scott (1994) 9 Cal.4th 331). An unauthorized sentence is the exception.
  • An upper term now generally requires aggravating facts found true by a jury or the judge in a court trial beyond a reasonable doubt, stipulated to, or based on certified records of prior convictions (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (b)).
  • Judges have broad power to dismiss enhancements in the furtherance of justice, and mitigating circumstances weigh greatly in favor of dismissal unless dismissal would endanger public safety (Pen. Code, § 1385, subd. (c); People v. Walker (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1024).
  • When the Court of Appeal vacates a sentence, the trial court generally conducts a full resentencing and may reconsider all of its choices (People v. Buycks (2018) 5 Cal.5th 857), but it generally may not impose a greater total sentence after a successful appeal (People v. Henderson (1963) 60 Cal.2d 482), unless the law never authorized the original sentence.
  • Usually, you must raise custody credit errors in the trial court first (Pen. Code, § 1237.1).
  • After a plea, a sentencing challenge needs a certificate of probable cause only if it attacks a sentence that was part of the bargain.

Which errors can a sentencing appeal raise?

ErrorExampleForfeited without an objection?
Unauthorized sentenceA term the statute does not allow, or an enhancement that cannot legally applyNo; the Court of Appeal may correct it
Upper term without required findingsThe judge relied on aggravating facts not found by a jury, stipulated to, or shown by certified recordsDepends on the timing of the case and the objection; often raised under the 2022 amendments
Failure to apply a lower-term presumptionYouth, childhood trauma, or other listed factors contributed to the offense, and the judge did not apply the presumption of the lower term (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (b)(6))Usually requires a request or objection
Failure to exercise informed discretionThe judge did not know it could strike an enhancement, a prior strike, or a firearm enhancementThe Court of Appeal may order a remand when the record shows the judge misunderstood its discretion
Improper refusal to dismiss an enhancementThe judge did not give mitigating circumstances the weight section 1385(c) requiresRequires an argument at sentencing
Multiple punishment barred by section 654Separate punishment for two offenses arising from one actNot forfeited; an error under section 654 can be raised on appeal
Custody and conduct creditsDays in custody miscountedMust usually be raised in the trial court first (Pen. Code, § 1237.1)
Fines, fees, and restitutionAmounts not authorized, or imposed without required findingsOften forfeited without objection, except unauthorized amounts
Probation conditionsA condition unrelated to the offense or overbroadRequires an objection, except facial constitutional challenges
Cruel or unusual punishmentA sentence grossly disproportionate to the offense and offenderUsually requires an objection; rarely successful

How did the 2022 sentencing changes affect a sentencing appeal?

Several laws that took effect January 1, 2022, changed how courts impose felony sentences and created many appellate issues.

LawChangeAppellate effect
Senate Bill 567 (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (b))The middle term became the default. An upper term requires aggravating facts that a jury finds true beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant admits, or that certified records of prior convictions showCourts may vacate sentences above the middle term in nonfinal cases unless the error was harmless; the California Supreme Court set the harmless error test in People v. Lynch (2024) 16 Cal.5th 730
Assembly Bill 124 (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (b)(6))The law presumes the lower term when childhood trauma, youth under 26, or being a victim of certain abuse contributed to the offenseRemand for resentencing when the court did not consider the presumption
Senate Bill 81 (Pen. Code, § 1385, subd. (c))Listed mitigating circumstances weigh greatly in favor of dismissing an enhancementRemand when the court did not apply the statute or misunderstood it
Assembly Bill 518 (Pen. Code, § 654)The court may choose which of two overlapping offenses to punish, instead of having to punish the longestRemand when the court did not know it had that choice
Senate Bill 483 (Pen. Code, § 1172.75)Most one-year prior prison term enhancements and certain prior drug enhancements became invalidFull resentencing where the court imposed those enhancements

The firm’s pages on Senate Bill 567 and Senate Bill 81 explain those laws in more detail.

When does a new law apply to a sentence already imposed?

A law that reduces punishment generally applies to every case that is not yet final on appeal, unless the Legislature says otherwise (In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740). A case is not final until the time for review in the California Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court has passed. That is one reason an appeal can matter even when the trial was fair: it keeps the case open so new sentencing laws can apply.

Some laws also create separate resentencing procedures for final cases, such as recall and resentencing under Penal Code section 1172.1 and resentencing under section 1172.75. The firm’s AB 600 resentencing page explains recall and resentencing.

What standard applies in a sentencing appeal?

ClaimStandard of review
Whether a statute authorizes the sentenceIndependent review
Choice among lower, middle, and upper termAbuse of discretion, if the court met the legal requirements
Refusal to strike a prior strike (a Romero motion)Abuse of discretion (People v. Carmony (2004) 33 Cal.4th 367)
Refusal to dismiss an enhancement under section 1385Abuse of discretion, applying the statute’s weighing rules (People v. Walker)
Facts underlying a section 654 rulingSubstantial evidence
Constitutional claims, such as cruel or unusual punishmentIndependent review of the legal question, with deference to factual findings

An abuse of discretion occurs when the judge’s decision was irrational or arbitrary, or when it was based on a misunderstanding of the law or of the scope of the judge’s discretion. The last category is where most sentencing appeals succeed.

What happens if the sentencing appeal succeeds?

ResultWhat follows
The Court of Appeal modifies the sentenceThis fits clear errors with only one correct result, such as striking an unauthorized fee or correcting credits
Remand for resentencingThe trial court holds a new sentencing hearing
Full resentencingWhen part of the sentence is vacated, the court generally may reconsider all sentencing choices (People v. Buycks)
Limit on a harsher sentenceAfter a successful appeal, the court generally cannot increase the total sentence (People v. Henderson), except to correct an unauthorized sentence
Plea casesIf the sentence was part of a plea bargain and a new law reduces it, the court may let the prosecution withdraw from the bargain in some situations (People v. Stamps (2020) 9 Cal.5th 685)

At a resentencing hearing, the defense can present new mitigation, including conduct and programming since the original sentence.

How does a sentencing appeal work, step by step?

  1. Object at sentencing to any discretionary choice the defense disagrees with, and ask the court to exercise every discretion it has.
  2. File a notice of appeal within 60 days in a felony case, or 30 days in a misdemeanor case.
  3. Raise custody credit errors in the trial court by motion first, if that is the only issue (Pen. Code, § 1237.1).
  4. Obtain the record, including the probation report, sentencing memoranda, and the transcript of the sentencing hearing.
  5. File the opening brief identifying each error and why it requires a new hearing.
  6. Respond to the Attorney General’s brief, which often argues forfeiture or harmless error.
  7. Prepare for resentencing, if the appeal succeeds, with updated mitigation.

What are the deadlines for a sentencing appeal?

A sentencing appeal starts with a notice of appeal, and the deadline depends on the type of case. Therefore, calendar the deadline the day the judge imposes sentence.

Case typeDeadline to file the notice of appealWhere the sentencing appeal goes
Felony60 days after the judgmentThe Court of Appeal for the district
Misdemeanor30 days after the judgmentThe appellate division of the superior court
Felony after a guilty or no contest plea60 days; a certificate of probable cause is generally not needed for sentencing issues that do not attack the pleaThe Court of Appeal
Probation violation sentence60 days in a felony case, 30 days in a misdemeanor caseThe same courts as above

In addition, if the only issue is custody credits, Penal Code section 1237.1 generally requires you to ask the trial court to fix the error first.

What records does a sentencing appeal use?

A sentencing appeal depends on the record. For that reason, your lawyer will review these documents closely:

RecordWhy it matters in a sentencing appeal
Reporter’s transcript of the sentencing hearingShows what the judge said, what the defense asked, and which objections the defense made
Probation reportLists the aggravating and mitigating factors the judge considered
Sentencing briefs and exhibitsShow the arguments and mitigation the defense presented
Minute orderRecords the sentence the court actually announced
Abstract of judgmentShows the sentence the prison or jail will carry out, which sometimes contains clerical errors

What makes a strong sentencing appeal?

A strong sentencing appeal usually has at least one of these features:

  • First, a sentence that no statute allows, which a court can correct at any time.
  • Next, an upper term based on facts that no jury found and the defendant never admitted, contrary to Penal Code section 1170.
  • Also, a judge who did not know about discretion to strike an enhancement under Penal Code section 1385.
  • Then, a new law that took effect before the case became final.
  • Finally, clear errors in custody credits, fines, or fees.

What mistakes can hurt a sentencing appeal?

  • Missing the notice of appeal deadline, which usually ends the appeal.
  • Failing to object at sentencing, which can forfeit discretionary issues.
  • Overlooking the abstract of judgment, which may not match the sentence the judge announced.
  • Arguing that the sentence feels too harsh, instead of showing a legal error.
  • Ignoring plea bargain risks, because in some cases the prosecution may withdraw from the deal if the sentence changes.

Three examples

Example 1: An upper term after 2022. A defendant received the upper term based on facts the judge found from the probation report. Because the case was not yet final when the law changed, the appeal argued that no jury found the facts and the defendant never stipulated to them. The Court of Appeal applied the harmless error test from Lynch and remanded for resentencing.

Example 2: An enhancement the judge thought it could not strike. The record showed the judge said a firearm enhancement was mandatory. The appeal argued the judge had discretion to strike it or impose a lesser enhancement (People v. Tirado (2022) 12 Cal.5th 688). The Court of Appeal remanded the case so the judge could exercise informed discretion.

Example 3: Section 654. A defendant received consecutive terms for two offenses committed in a single act with a single objective. The appeal argued section 654 barred separate punishment. The Court of Appeal stayed the term on one count.

These are illustrations, not case results. Outcomes depend on the record and the court.

Key terms

TermMeaning
Unauthorized sentenceA sentence the court could not lawfully impose under any circumstance in the case
ForfeitureLoss of the right to raise an issue on appeal because no one raised it in the trial court
Upper, middle, and lower termThe three possible terms for most felonies
EnhancementAn additional term added for a specific fact, such as firearm use or a prior conviction
Romero motionA request to dismiss a prior strike in the interest of justice
Section 654The rule against multiple punishment for a single act or course of conduct
RemandReturning the case to the trial court for further proceedings
Full resentencingA new sentencing hearing at which the court may reconsider all of its choices

How does a sentencing appeal compare with other ways to change a sentence?

RouteWhen it fitsTiming
Direct appealLegal errors at sentencing that appear in the record60 days after judgment in a felony case; 30 days in a misdemeanor case
Recall and resentencing (Pen. Code, § 1172.1)The court may recall a sentence on its own motion within 120 days, or at any time if the applicable sentencing laws have changed; the prosecutor or corrections officials may also request itVaries
Resentencing for invalid prior prison term enhancements (Pen. Code, § 1172.75)The court imposed a now-invalid one-year enhancementThrough the statutory process
Petition for writ of habeas corpusErrors based on facts outside the record, or an unauthorized sentence in a final caseWithout substantial delay
Motion to correct custody creditsMiscounted creditsAny time, in the trial court
Motion to reduce a wobbler to a misdemeanor (Pen. Code, § 17, subd. (b))An eligible felony after the court granted probationUsually after the court grants probation, often at its end

The firm’s motion to modify a sentence page explains requests made to the sentencing court.

How can the defense protect a sentencing appeal at the hearing?

  1. File a sentencing memorandum that cites every statute giving the court discretion, including sections 1170(b)(6) and 1385(c).
  2. Present mitigation evidence, including evidence of childhood trauma, youth, mental illness, or abuse when it contributed to the offense.
  3. Object to every aggravating fact that no jury found, that the defendant did not admit, and that no certified record shows.
  4. Ask the court to state its reasons for each discretionary choice on the record.
  5. Ask the court to strike or reduce enhancements, including substituting a lesser firearm enhancement where permitted.
  6. Raise section 654 for offenses arising from one act or objective.
  7. Object to fines, fees, and probation conditions that lack legal authority, lack support, or reach too far.
  8. Confirm the custody credits before the hearing ends.

A clear record of what the defense asked and what the judge said is the foundation of a sentencing appeal. A judge’s statement that a choice was “mandatory” when it was not is often the key line in the transcript.

Does a misdemeanor sentencing appeal work the same way?

A misdemeanor sentencing appeal goes to the appellate division of the superior court within 30 days. The issues are similar but simpler: unauthorized jail terms or fines, improper probation conditions, and misapplication of statutes such as the one-year limit on most misdemeanor probation (Pen. Code, § 1203a). The firm’s misdemeanor appeals page explains that process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you appeal a sentence in California?

Yes. You can file a sentencing appeal with the conviction appeal or by itself. The notice of appeal is due within 60 days in a felony case and 30 days in a misdemeanor case.

Can I file a sentencing appeal if I pleaded guilty?

Yes, if you are challenging how the judge exercised discretion within the range the plea allowed, or a legal error at sentencing. If you are challenging a sentence that was part of the plea bargain, you need a certificate of probable cause.

What is an unauthorized sentence?

A sentence that the law does not allow under any circumstances in the case, such as a term longer than the statute permits. The Court of Appeal can correct it even if no one objected.

Can the judge give me more time after I win a sentencing appeal?

Generally no. California law bars a greater total sentence after a successful appeal, except when the law never authorized the original sentence.

What does Senate Bill 567 mean for my sentence?

Since 2022, the middle term is the default, and an upper term generally requires aggravating facts found true beyond a reasonable doubt, admitted, or shown by certified records of prior convictions. You may challenge sentences that did not follow these rules if the case was not yet final.

Can new sentencing laws apply to my case after sentencing?

Yes, if the case is not yet final on appeal and the law reduces punishment, unless the Legislature said otherwise. Some laws also create resentencing procedures for final cases.

How does a sentencing appeal fix custody credit errors?

Usually by a motion in the trial court first. If credits are the only issue, the appeal generally cannot proceed until you ask the trial court to correct them.

What is a Romero motion?

A request asking the judge to dismiss a prior strike conviction in the interest of justice. The Court of Appeal reviews a denial for abuse of discretion.

Can I appeal a restitution order?

Yes. A restitution order is part of the judgment or an appealable order after judgment. Usually, you need objections at the restitution hearing to preserve challenges to the amount.

Can I appeal a probation condition?

Yes, but you usually must object at sentencing. However, you can challenge a condition that is unconstitutional on its face without an objection.

How long does a sentencing appeal take?

Commonly nine months to a year and a half in a felony case, depending on the record and extensions.

What if my lawyer did not object at sentencing?

You may forfeit the issue, but the appeal can argue that the failure to object was ineffective assistance, and some errors, such as an unauthorized sentence, do not require an objection.

Is a long sentence cruel and unusual punishment?

Rarely. A sentence violates the state or federal constitution only if it is grossly disproportionate to the offense and the offender. Most challenges on that ground fail.

What happens at a resentencing hearing?

The trial court imposes a new sentence. In a full resentencing, it may reconsider all of its choices, and the defense may present new mitigation, including conduct since the original sentence.

Can a judge recall my sentence without an appeal?

Yes, in some cases. Under Penal Code section 1172.1, the court may recall and resentence on its own motion within 120 days of commitment, or at any time if the sentencing laws have changed, and prosecutors and corrections officials may also request it.

What is the difference between a sentencing appeal and resentencing?

An appeal asks the Court of Appeal to find legal error in the original sentence. Resentencing is a new hearing in the trial court, which may follow a successful appeal or a statutory resentencing procedure.

Do I need a new lawyer for a sentencing appeal?

Not necessarily, but appellate work is different from trial work. An appellate lawyer reviews the record for legal error, and a lawyer who did not handle the sentencing can more freely evaluate whether trial counsel’s performance was deficient.

Can a sentencing appeal reduce my time in custody?

It can. For example, striking an enhancement, correcting credits, or ordering a lower term can shorten the sentence. However, the result depends on the error and the record.

Do I need a lawyer for a sentencing appeal?

California does not require one, and the court appoints counsel for people who cannot afford a lawyer in a felony appeal. Still, a sentencing appeal turns on detailed legal research, so experienced appellate counsel matters.

  • Penal Code sections 654, 1170, 1172.1, 1172.75, 1237, 1237.1, 1237.5, and 1385
  • California Constitution, article I, section 17; United States Constitution, Eighth Amendment
  • People v. Scott (1994) 9 Cal.4th 331
  • People v. Lynch (2024) 16 Cal.5th 730
  • People v. Walker (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1024
  • People v. Buycks (2018) 5 Cal.5th 857
  • People v. Henderson (1963) 60 Cal.2d 482
  • People v. Carmony (2004) 33 Cal.4th 367
  • People v. Tirado (2022) 12 Cal.5th 688
  • People v. Stamps (2020) 9 Cal.5th 685
  • In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740

Talk to a Criminal Appeals Lawyer

Power Trial Lawyers handles criminal appeals in California, including sentencing appeals and resentencing. The firm has obtained appellate relief on sentencing issues, including a sentence vacated under Penal Code 1170(b)(6). Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. A plea case may need a certificate of probable cause; the firm’s appeal after a guilty plea page explains when. The firm represents anyone who needs representation within its practice areas, provided it has no conflict of interest. Call (888) 808-2179 or contact the firm.

This page provides general information about California law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Sentencing law changes often, and whether a new law applies depends on the case’s status. Last updated November 2026.

Client Reviews

Matthew is the most knowledgeable lawyer. I have worked with teams of lawyers and none of them were as knowledgeable and prompt as Matthew. I trust all of my company’s legal affairs with Matthew. He makes me rest easy knowing he is on it.

Michael

Matthew is the epitome of hard work and dedication, when it comes to his work. Matthew has helped me with all my contractual work needed to help me launch my start up. Matthew is honest, diligent and relentless.

Carol

Matthew was very responsive and caring for my case. He handled my case with efficiency and made sure to secure exactly what we wanted. He has represented my company previously and when we needed a lawyer, it was no question – we phoned Matthew!

Tony

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Appeals and Litigation Attorney
Fill out the contact form or call us at (888) 808-2179 to schedule your free consultation.

Get In Touch