Understanding the Appeals Process: A Guide by a California Criminal Defense and Appeals Lawyer

Navigating the criminal justice system can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to the intricacies of the appeals process. For those convicted of crimes in California, understanding the rights and procedures related to direct appeals is crucial. This article provides a comprehensive analysis of the appeals process. This guide is particularly valuable for individuals seeking the expertise of a California Criminal Defense and Appeals Lawyer.

Introduction to Direct Appeals

Any person convicted of a crime in California has the right to a direct appeal from the final judgment, typically the commitment to prison or other sentencing orders. Direct appeals are also available to those who have been civilly committed as Mentally Disordered Offenders (MDOs) or Sexually Violent Predators (SVPs). The appeals process is an essential legal mechanism, allowing higher courts to review potential legal errors made during the trial or sentencing that could have affected the outcome.

Filing a Notice of Appeal

The first step in the appeals process is filing a notice of appeal. This notice must be filed within 60 days after the final judgment or order being appealed. The notice can be signed by the defendant or their attorney and must identify the case name, number, and the judgment being appealed. For those challenging the validity of a guilty or no contest plea, a request for a certificate of probable cause must also be filed.

Constructive Filing of a Late Notice of Appeal

In certain circumstances, individuals may be allowed to file a late notice of appeal under the principle of “constructive filing.” This can apply if, for example, the notice was timely delivered to prison staff for mailing but delayed, or if the defendant relied on assurances from their attorney that were not fulfilled. Constructive filing requires a motion with the court of appeal or a petition for writ of habeas corpus.

Issues Raised on Appeal After a Trial

Various legal issues can be raised on appeal, including violations of constitutional rights or state laws. However, the appeal must be based on evidence and proceedings recorded in the superior court. If the issue was not raised during the trial, the court of appeal may consider it forfeited unless it’s of constitutional importance or an objection in the superior court would have been futile.

Issues Raised on Appeal After a Guilty or No Contest Plea

Appeals following a guilty or no contest plea are more limited. Issues that can be raised include challenges to the denial of a motion to suppress illegally obtained evidence or claims that the court or prosecutor violated the plea bargain. Some appeals require a certificate of probable cause, such as those challenging the plea’s validity.

Appellate Counsel and Court Transcripts

Indigent appellants are entitled to appointed counsel and court transcripts provided at state expense. Appellate attorneys review trial records to identify potential appealable issues and prepare necessary briefs.

Record Correction and Augmentation

Appellate attorneys ensure the record is complete and may file motions to augment the record if additional documents or transcripts are needed. This ensures that all relevant materials are available for the court of appeal’s review.

Appellate Briefing

The appeals process involves multiple rounds of briefing. The appellant files an opening brief outlining the legal errors and desired remedies. The respondent, represented by the state, files a counter-brief, followed by the appellant’s reply brief. Supplemental briefs may be filed if new issues arise.

Oral Argument and Decision

The court of appeal may schedule oral arguments where attorneys can address the judges’ questions. Following the arguments, the court issues its decision, which could affirm, reverse, or modify the original judgment. The court might also remand the case for further proceedings.

Petition for Rehearing and Review

If dissatisfied with the court of appeal’s decision, parties can file a petition for rehearing or seek review by the California Supreme Court. The Supreme Court reviews cases of significant legal importance but grants review in only a small fraction of cases.

How a California Criminal Defense and Appeals Lawyer Can Help

Navigating the complexities of the appeals process requires the expertise of a California Criminal Defense and Appeals Lawyer. An experienced attorney can:

  • Evaluate Eligibility: Assessing whether there are valid grounds for an appeal.
  • Preparing and Filing Appeals: Ensuring all procedural requirements are met and presenting compelling arguments.
  • Representation in Court: Advocating on behalf of the appellant during oral arguments and hearings.
  • Post-Appeal Actions: Filing petitions for rehearing or seeking review by higher courts if necessary.

If you believe you or a loved one may have grounds for an appeal, contact our law firm today. You can consult with our attorney team by calling 213-800-7664. Our California Criminal Defense and Appeals Lawyers are dedicated to providing the guidance and representation needed to navigate this complex process. Call us or submit a contact form to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help you achieve a fair and just outcome.

Justia Lawyer Rating
State Bar of California
The National Trial Lawyers Top 40 under 40
The National Trial Lawyers, Top 100 trial lawyers
Best Lawyers
Lawyers of Distinction
Super Lawyers
Super Lawyers Rising Stars
Contact Information