A Guide for California Defendants and Seeking a Direct Appeal By a California Criminal Appeals Lawyer

Facing a guilty verdict in California is one of the most overwhelming experiences a person and their family can endure. Whether the conviction came after a jury trial, court trial, open plea, or negotiated plea, the days and weeks immediately following sentencing are critical. This is the period during which defendants must protect their rights, preserve appellate issues, and make time-sensitive decisions—including whether to file a direct criminal appeal.

California law imposes strict, unforgiving deadlines. Most importantly:

You only have 60 days from the judgment to file a Notice of Appeal in a felony or misdemeanor case.

Miss this deadline, and you permanently lose the right to a direct appeal—no exceptions, no extensions, no second chances.

This article is written for defendants and family members across Los Angeles, Orange County, Riverside, San Bernardino, Ventura, the Bay Area, Sacramento, and all of California who are searching for clarity after a conviction. It is also designed to help individuals avoid the most common—and most damaging—post-verdict mistakes seen in criminal cases.

As a statewide California criminal appeals lawyer, Power Trial Lawyers handles felony and misdemeanor appeals from every Superior Court jurisdiction in the state. We prepared this guide to help you avoid the pitfalls that could cost you your appellate rights.

Mistake #1: Waiting Too Long to File the Notice of Appeal

The most devastating mistake people make after a guilty verdict is waiting. Many defendants think: “I’ll deal with this after sentencing” or “Let me get through prison intake first.” Even worse, California defendants think “my trial lawyer will file it for me” or “I have 90 days, right?” (Incorrect.)

California Rules of Court, rule 8.308(a), states that a defendant has 60 days from the date judgment is entered to file a Notice of Appeal.

Not 90 days.
Not “after intake.”
Not “whenever I’m ready.”

Exactly 60 days.

If the Notice of Appeal is not filed by Day 60, the right to a direct criminal appeal is lost forever. Even the Court of Appeal cannot grant relief after the deadline. There is no motion to extend time. There is no exception for hardship, confusion, jail transfers, or attorney error.

How to Avoid This Mistake

• Contact a California criminal appeals attorney immediately.
• File the Notice of Appeal as soon as possible—even before sentencing, if necessary.
• Allow your appellate lawyer to handle the filing, service, and confirmation.
• Confirm receipt of the Notice in the Superior Court docket.

The earlier the Notice is filed, the sooner transcripts can be requested and the record prepared, which accelerates the entire appellate process.

Mistake #2: Believing Your Trial Lawyer Will “Handle the Appeal”

Another common misconception is that the trial attorney automatically files the Notice of Appeal or continues representation into the appellate stage.

Reality:

Most trial lawyers do not file appeals, do not specialize in appeals, and do not continue representing clients once judgment has been entered.

Under California law:

• A trial attorney has no ongoing duty to pursue or file an appeal unless a separate agreement exists.
• The appellate process is fundamentally different from trial work and requires a specialized appeals lawyer.

Trial lawyers focus on jury selection, motions, negotiations, and sentencing. Appellate lawyers focus on legal error, constitutional violations, record analysis, issue identification, and briefing. These are completely different skill sets.

What Happens When Defendants Assume Their Lawyer Will File It?

• The 60-day appeal deadline passes.
• Family members assume the lawyer “took care of it.”
• Clients later discover no Notice was filed.
• The appeal is permanently barred.

How to Avoid This Mistake

• Do NOT assume your trial lawyer is filing anything.
• Ask explicitly: “Are you filing my Notice of Appeal?”
• Get it in writing.
• Ideally, retain a California criminal appeal attorney within days of the verdict.

Power Trial Lawyers routinely steps in immediately after sentencing to secure appellate rights statewide.

Mistake #3: Not Ordering (or Delaying) the Trial Transcripts

A criminal appeal in California is built entirely on the record of the case, which includes:

• Reporter’s transcripts (everything said in court)
• Clerk’s transcripts (motions, filings, exhibits, jury instructions, minute orders, verdict forms, etc.)

If transcripts are missing, incomplete, or delayed, the entire appeal stalls.

Why Transcripts Are Critical

Appellate courts review only what happened in the courtroom—not what happened outside of it. Appellate lawyers rely on the written record to identify:

• Evidentiary errors
• Constitutional violations
• Misconduct
• Bad jury instructions
• Sentencing errors
• Denials of motions (e.g., 995, 1538.5, 1118.1, new trial motions)
• Prosecutorial or judicial misconduct

If transcripts are not prepared promptly:

• The opening brief deadline cannot be set.
• The CDCR intake process may delay communication.
• Issues may become harder to identify.
• Witness recollections fade.
• The appeal timeline extends significantly.

California’s Process

After filing the Notice of Appeal:

• The court reporter must prepare the transcripts.
• The appellate division clerk assembles the clerk’s transcript.
• The Court of Appeal sends a notice confirming receipt of the record.

Delays on any of these steps slow the case.

How to Avoid This Mistake

• Have an appellate lawyer immediately file a Designation of Record.
• Follow up with court reporters (many are behind).
• Track transcript production deadlines.
• Ensure supplemental transcripts (e.g., sidebars, in camera hearings) are included.

A seasoned California criminal appeals attorney knows how to push transcript production forward and resolve missing-record issues quickly. Contact us today to consult with a California Criminal Appeals Lawyer at 888-808-2179.

Mistake #4: Misunderstanding What an Appeal Actually Does

One of the most damaging misunderstandings after a guilty verdict is the belief that a criminal appeal is a second trial. Families often assume the appellate court will hear new evidence, new testimony, or revisit the factual disputes that occurred during trial. In reality, a California criminal appeal is a highly specialized legal review of what happened in the Superior Court, not a re-litigation of the underlying case. The Court of Appeal examines the trial record for legal errors or constitutional violations that may have affected the fairness of the proceedings or the validity of the judgment.

Some defendants mistakenly think they cannot appeal because they “lost fair and square,” or because the jury “just believed the other side.” Others believe they can present new facts or bring forward witnesses who were not called. These misunderstandings lead to delays, missed deadlines, and lost opportunities. The appellate process is strictly limited to reviewing what occurred below. If the trial judge made errors, if counsel failed to object, if improper evidence was admitted, or if the jury received flawed instructions, those issues may form the basis of a reversible error. But none of this is possible unless the appeal is filed on time.

To avoid this mistake, it is essential to speak with a California criminal appeals attorney immediately after the verdict. A proper consultation clarifies what an appeal can and cannot do, explains timelines, and identifies whether there are viable issues for appellate review. Many defendants initially think their situation is hopeless, only to later learn that a strong appeal exists once the record is examined. Understanding the true function of a direct appeal allows you to make informed decisions early—precisely when timing matters most.

Mistake #5: Assuming a Plea Deal Cannot Be Appealed

Even a guilty plea can be appealed. A surprising number of people believe that entering a plea—especially a negotiated plea—eliminates any right to appeal. While it is true that guilty pleas limit the types of issues a defendant may raise, they absolutely do not eliminate the ability to file a direct appeal. Under California law, a defendant may still challenge matters such as jurisdictional defects, constitutional violations, sentencing errors, ineffective assistance of counsel that impacted the voluntariness of the plea, and any issue expressly preserved through a certificate of probable cause.

The misunderstanding often stems from confusing trial rights with appellate rights. A defendant who pleads guilty waives many trial rights, but does not waive the right to challenge the legality of the proceedings or the sentence imposed. This mistake is especially costly because defendants who enter pleas are often rushed through sentencing and transferred to custody quickly, making the 60-day deadline even more critical.

Avoiding this mistake requires early intervention. A qualified criminal appeal attorney in California will evaluate whether the plea was lawfully entered, whether the court properly advised the defendant, whether counsel explained the consequences, and whether the sentencing judge exceeded statutory authority. Many plea-based appeals ultimately lead to resentencing, withdrawals of pleas, or other significant relief. The key is to act quickly, because the right to appeal still expires exactly 60 days after judgment, regardless of whether the conviction was by plea or trial.

Mistake #6: Failing to Preserve Sentencing Issues

Sentencing is often treated as an afterthought, especially when the verdict has already been delivered. However, the sentencing hearing is one of the most important stages for preserving appellate arguments. In California, issues not raised in the trial court are frequently deemed forfeited on appeal, meaning the Court of Appeal will not consider them. This includes improper enhancements, incorrect term calculations, unauthorized sentences, misapplications of mandatory mitigation statutes such as Penal Code section 1170(b), or violations involving aggravating factor findings.

Many defendants assume the trial lawyer will raise every necessary objection. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Sentencing hearings move quickly, and defense counsel is often overwhelmed with last-minute reports, probation recommendations, and amendment requests from the prosecution. When objections are not made clearly and specifically, valuable issues are lost.

To avoid this mistake, a defendant should engage an appellate lawyer immediately after conviction so that sentencing issues can be identified and communicated to trial counsel before the hearing. An experienced California felony appeal lawyer understands which errors most often lead to reversals or resentencing and can ensure the record is properly preserved. Even if sentencing has already occurred, an appellate review may still uncover unauthorized or improperly calculated terms that an appellate court has the authority to correct.

Mistake #7: Waiting Until Prison Intake Before Seeking Help

One of the most common phrases we hear from families is, “Let’s wait until he gets processed into CDCR before dealing with the appeal.” This is a dangerous misconception and often results in the loss of critical rights. The intake process can take weeks. Transfers between county jail, Wasco, Chino, or CIW often disrupt communication completely. During this time, defendants may not have access to phones, mail, or their legal paperwork. Meanwhile, the appellate deadline continues running.

Families understandably feel overwhelmed after sentencing and want a moment to breathe. But the appellate courts do not pause the clock to accommodate that emotional processing period. The countdown to the Notice of Appeal deadline begins immediately, regardless of where the defendant is housed or whether CDCR has completed reception.

Avoiding this mistake requires recognizing that the period immediately after sentencing is the most important window for contacting a statewide California criminal appeals lawyer. The appellate attorney can file the Notice of Appeal even before intake is completed and can begin initiating the record designation process so that transcripts are not delayed. Waiting until after reception creates unnecessary risks and often leaves only days or hours before the deadline.

Mistake #8: Hiring a Lawyer Who Does Not Specialize in Criminal Appeals

Many people panic after a guilty verdict and hire the first lawyer who promises results. But an attorney who excels at trials, negotiations, or pretrial motions may not be equipped to handle an appeal. Trial work is fast, reactive, and focused on witnesses and courtroom performance. Appellate work is methodical, analytical, and grounded in constitutional law, statutory interpretation, and written advocacy.

A criminal appeal in California requires the ability to dissect thousands of pages of transcripts, identify legal error, craft sophisticated arguments, and anticipate how appellate justices will view the case. A trial lawyer who is not trained in appeals may miss issues, misunderstand standards of review, or fail to structure briefs in a persuasive and legally precise manner. Worse, some non-appellate lawyers file Notices of Appeal without understanding the steps that follow, leaving clients confused, unrepresented, and at risk of missing record designations or briefing deadlines.

Choosing the right attorney is essential. A California criminal appeals lawyer should be able to show prior appellate decisions, sample briefs, published or unpublished victories, and experience appearing before the Court of Appeal. You should feel confident that your appellate lawyer understands not just legal argumentation, but also the nuance of appellate procedure and the expectations of appellate courts statewide.

When a conviction has the power to alter a person’s life forever, the appeal should not be trusted to someone who does not practice full-time in this field. Specialized skill matters.

Mistake #9: Ignoring Post-Trial Motions That Strengthen the Appeal

After a guilty verdict, many defendants believe the only remaining step is the sentencing hearing. But California law allows for several post-trial motions that, if filed properly and on time, can significantly strengthen a later direct appeal. Among these are:

• Motion for new trial (Penal Code § 1181)
• Romero motion or other strike-dismissal motions
• Sentencing memoranda that preserve objections
• Motions addressing juror misconduct or judicial error

When a motion for new trial is made, it forces the trial judge to address alleged errors directly. Even if denied, the motion creates a valuable appellate record because the Court of Appeal can review not only the error itself, but also the judge’s rationale for rejecting the defense argument.

Unfortunately, defendants frequently miss the opportunity to file such motions because they assume they are unnecessary or because trial counsel is too drained after trial to put forward robust post-trial litigation. Others simply do not realize these motions exist.

Avoiding this mistake requires immediate communication with an appellate attorney who can identify which post-trial motions should be filed before judgment is pronounced. These motions often lay the foundation for appellate success. Without them, key arguments may be harder to raise or may be deemed forfeited.

Mistake #10: Losing Hope and Failing to Take Action

Perhaps the most heartbreaking mistake is the emotional paralysis that follows a guilty verdict. People often feel defeated, hopeless, or overwhelmed. Families withdraw. Defendants retreat inward. And because the appellate deadline continues ticking regardless of human emotion, time is lost.

A criminal conviction in California is not the end of the road. Many cases win relief on appeal, sometimes through reversal, sometimes through remand for resentencing, sometimes through striking enhancements, and sometimes through reversal of specific findings that change the entire structure of the sentence. Even when a full reversal is not possible, the appellate courts regularly correct sentencing errors, apply new laws retroactively, or remand cases based on procedural irregularities.

Taking action is the single most important step a defendant or family member can take. Filing the Notice of Appeal costs nothing, preserves all rights, and keeps the possibility of justice alive. Once the appeal is filed, a California felony appeal lawyer can assess the record methodically and present the strongest arguments available under the law.

Hope is not naïve—it is procedural. It is strategic. And it is necessary.

Protecting Your Future Starts Now

The days and weeks following a guilty verdict or sentencing hearing are some of the most critical in the entire lifespan of a criminal case. Mistakes made during this period can permanently eliminate appellate rights or weaken arguments that would otherwise lead to relief. The California criminal appeals system is unforgiving in its timelines and highly technical in its requirements. Yet it offers powerful remedies for those who act quickly and strategically.

If you or your loved one has been convicted anywhere in California—Los Angeles County, Orange County, Riverside, San Bernardino, Ventura, Sacramento, San Diego, the Bay Area, or any other jurisdiction—your appellate rights may already be running. Understanding the top mistakes and how to avoid them is essential, but guidance from a seasoned appellate lawyer is even more critical.

Power Trial Lawyers represents criminal appeals clients statewide, handling direct appeals in every California Court of Appeal district. Our role is to protect your rights, identify the strongest appellate issues, and provide a clear path forward at a time when clarity matters most.

Your time to act is short. Your rights remain powerful. And your future is still worth fighting for.

Consult With a California Appeals Lawyer Today

If you or your family member was recently convicted or sentenced in California, contact Power Trial Lawyers immediately. Your appellate deadline may already be approaching, and waiting even a few days could jeopardize your right to challenge the conviction.

Call today: 888-808-2179
Statewide California Criminal Appeals Representation
Direct Appeals • Felony Appeals • Sentencing Errors • Constitutional Violations

Your appeal starts with one step: preserving your rights before it’s too late.

Frequently Asked Questions